76 points by mikhael 6 hours ago | 3 comments
dako2117 4 hours ago
JohnKemeny 1 hour ago
paulpauper 3 hours ago
It's interesting how so many important papers are always on arxiv first. it makes me wonder what purpose peer reviews serves. I think also, this is to help establish priority over the result. So getting it up on arxiv is like a timestamp to avoid someone else deriving it at the same time and getting credit by having it published first.
pepinator 2 hours ago
Peer review is important for checking the correctness of the results, among other things. It's not uncommon to find big errors; small mistakes are everywhere.
trod1234 2 hours ago
Its easier to tear down than build up. Resilient structures are tested structures and last the longest.
lokimedes 1 hour ago
The purpose of the (pre-print) arChive is to allow for a wider circulation during review. That many today simply leave their stuff on Arxiv without publishing is arguably a bit of “cargoculting”, as it signals legitimacy without any quality control.
SpaceManNabs 2 hours ago
The article does a wonderful job in providing context for the proof.

I really enjoyed the clear descriptions of the three scales.